SB Nation Tampa Bay Editor's Pick
Why 18 games is two too many.
I think a 18 game regular season is stupid and a move that will be made out of greed. That is my personal opinion and maybe after reading this your opinion on this matter will change. Please note I'm obviously not a head coach, owner or a NFL player and do not speak for everyone. This is just a way to express arguments that "can" be made for each side. Of course there will be many of you who disagree or agree with my reasonings. Please share your comments and add anything I've missed. I know there will be a lot.
I will be looking at the many different perspectives of the addition of 2 regular season games to the schedule.
As a pure football fan: GREAT! Two more meaningful games to entertain me. What do I care about players getting injured or careers being shortened? I get to watch games that matter and not wait for a month of preseason to go by and get out of the way. It will be interesting to watch how the added stats will break old records and the new standards of a bad, decent, or great season will be.
Conclusion: Nothing to lose, only gain.
As a head coach: Great... More work for me to do. Now I have to take in effect about how often I use my players and have to come up with potential ways to keep them from injuring themselves such as in practice. How much will my pay be increased? How many more players will I be able to have on my roster, practice squad, and active game day roster? Will I have a second bye week to plan for? Now I only have 2 preseason games to judge the talent on my roster. QB competition? The results of one won't be that accurate.
Conclusion: Same amount of time, more work.
As an owner: GREAT! More money for me! As if i don't make enough as it is! What do I care about the wear and tear on the human body? I'm not a player. I get to sit back and enjoy two more games worth of revenue! Excuse me while I go sit on my golden toilet.
Conclusion: More $
As an NFL player: Great... Now I have to be more worried about how I spend my money in case of an injury and to make sure I'll be financialy stable. I have to endure the pain of 18 games. Now 1,000 rushing yards will still be a milestone but not as good as it once was. 1,000 recieving yards? Big deal. Wow. Look at all the records that have been broken. How much more money will I be recieving this year? Will I even make the roster seeing as I only have 2 games to make an impression. Will I win the competition for my starting roster spot in that amount of time?
Conclusion: They have it the worst and don't really benefit from anything. Almost all NFL players I've heard are against the idea of two more games.
Content provided by a member of Bucs Nation and does not necessarily reflect the view or opinions of Bucs Nation.
22 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I think you hit all main points right on target
There was a poll somewhere on one of the NFL sites and I was suprised most votes were against expanding the season. But as other’s have said before expanding the regular season expands the pie. Which benefits both owners and players. Players have to decide whether those two pieces of pie are worth the potential injuries.
Perhaps with an expanded roster
the 18 game schedule is not a bad ides. They play the games anyway – they just don’t count now and I, for one, can’t seem to get enough football.
I vote “yay”
Definately
I’ve been listening to Sirius radio and they think that the free agent year should be dropped from 4(?) to 3(?) if it was implented.
That's what I think.
If there are going to be more games, they need to allow a bigger roster size and practice squad. This would give teams a chance to work in rotations at key positions and lessen stress on players.
Also, something to consider. Maybe a 2nd bye week?
The key to this is going to be the CBA
From what I’ve seen, the potential 18-game schedule is being used by the owners as a bargaining chip. Now, the owners are pushing for a reduction in player costs and they’re prepared to lock out the players if hey have to. Neither side wants this, but the owners have the leverage here. Now they’re going to go to the players and say “Look, we won’t reduce player costs or we’ll reduce them less – if you accept 18 games in a season.”
More games doesn't mean more money, unless it's from TV.
Season ticket holders still have to purchase preseason games at the same price as the regular season games, and believe it or not, well before the financial woes of the world, they sold out too. That being said, home teams do not have to share ticket sales of preseason games, and the players aren’t getting paid much because their contract money doesn’t kick in until week 1 of the regular season. So they are making some good money on preseason games, which is why there have been four of them for so long.
I think an 18 game regular season and a shortened preseason is from the number of season ending injuries that have been happening in the preseason. So if there are going to be injuries, they should be when it really counts, not to mention that preseason games are rather boring. I wouldn’t count out the major networks lobbying for this as well, more advertising for them.
Me personally, I think I’d cut the preseason down to two games and look into more playoff teams and games.
If an optimist had his left arm chewed off by an alligator, he might say in a pleasant and hopeful voice, "Well this isn't to bad, I don't have a left arm anymore but at least nobody will ever ask me if I'm left-handed or right-handed" but most of us would say something more along the lines of "Aaaaaa! My arm! My arm!" DANIEL HANDLER (as Lemony Snicket)
You're spot on
It means more money from TV contracts – and TV contracts are the biggest source of income for the NFL.
I’d hate to look into more playoff teams, though. At this point 12 of the 32 teams get into the playoffs, expand it any more and you’re going to significantly decrease the relevance of the regular season.
That's why I said look into it.
I really don’t want an 18 game season, it’s more pressure on the fans too. Preseason games are the only games I can watch and not be stressed out about.
If an optimist had his left arm chewed off by an alligator, he might say in a pleasant and hopeful voice, "Well this isn't to bad, I don't have a left arm anymore but at least nobody will ever ask me if I'm left-handed or right-handed" but most of us would say something more along the lines of "Aaaaaa! My arm! My arm!" DANIEL HANDLER (as Lemony Snicket)
My biggest problem for some reason is
that undrafted free agents that can become potential pro bowlers won’t be found.
Tony Romo? Cut before he becomes a household name like he is today.
Terrel Davis? Never ends up in the HOF.
Those are just 2 examples. We could have a diamond in the rough and not be able to find out he is because he only played sparringly in 2 preseason games. To me that isn’t worth the risk.
"You have to play this game like somebody just hit your mother with a two-by-four."
-Dan Birdwell
Peyton Manning in an interview on NFL.com said that Jeff Saturday never would've made the NFL without all 4 preseason games
My point exactly
"You have to play this game like somebody just hit your mother with a two-by-four."
-Dan Birdwell
I am not advocating an 18 game season
But you could add more training camp 2 scrimmages. Expand roster to 63.
I think that players can, and are, evaluated more on the practice field...
than during the pre-season games. If an 18 game schedule and a rookie wage scale come out of the new collective bargaining agreement negotiations, the NFL will be all the better for it. Let the players play and the owners make their millions. There is apparently enough money to go around.
A rookie wage scale is something I will back 200%
But i believe preseason games are move valuable for evaluating because its against a different team and players that could also be trying to make the roster. No matter how much you may practice, theres no substitution for the real thing.
"You have to play this game like somebody just hit your mother with a two-by-four."
-Dan Birdwell
Got to have the rookie wage scale
These unproven guys are making a fortune based on their draft position. It’s ridiculous. But I think the players cave on the 18 game schedule.
18 games
Well, not really, if there’s 2 bye weeks. That means 2 more weeks of TV revenue for the cost of only week to owners. Sold.
Given an added bye week, expanded rosters, and expanded contracts, I believe the players would be for such an expansion. As a bonus, many NFL records will be easier (slightly) to break, thus increasing the chance for immortality. Decreasing the number of preseason games means the chance for injury should’nt increase significantly. An extra week of rest might actually do more to preserve player’s bodies.
As a coach, I can definitely see this whole thing as a headache. There will be many unforseen consequences of such a change and coaches will have to take responsibility for many of them. They will adjust, though, and they’re concerns are really secondary to the concerns of the fans, owners, or players.
I’m for it. Chances are, it will probably happen eventually no matter what. Money(gangsters) makes the world go round.
5 picks out of the first 100 in a draft saturated with talent. Yes, I'm optimistic.
My opinion on the bye weeks is they should just keep it at one, but every team should have their bye week in the middle of the season all together.
Not saying the entire league take a week off, I’m saying half the league should have a week off and the rest the next week. Having bye weeks at week 4 is dumb, and they used to have them earlier.
If an optimist had his left arm chewed off by an alligator, he might say in a pleasant and hopeful voice, "Well this isn't to bad, I don't have a left arm anymore but at least nobody will ever ask me if I'm left-handed or right-handed" but most of us would say something more along the lines of "Aaaaaa! My arm! My arm!" DANIEL HANDLER (as Lemony Snicket)
Over the course of am 18 game season...
a second bye week would probably be welcomed. The timing of these bye week needs to be improved, as a Week 4 bye is useless. It really benefits a team to have one later in the year – which is exactly when you need the rest.
Two bye weeks and an 18 game season keeps the NFL on my TV screen for two more weeks, and I am all for that. Go Bucs!
by Cracker Ball on Sep 3, 2010 11:29 AM EDT up reply actions
I'd rather have 1 bye and 16 games.
If an optimist had his left arm chewed off by an alligator, he might say in a pleasant and hopeful voice, "Well this isn't to bad, I don't have a left arm anymore but at least nobody will ever ask me if I'm left-handed or right-handed" but most of us would say something more along the lines of "Aaaaaa! My arm! My arm!" DANIEL HANDLER (as Lemony Snicket)
+1
I am happy with the format as it is for the season
by ShiftyShayne on Sep 5, 2010 10:38 PM EDT up reply actions




















